Area coroner Alison Longhorn told an inquest at Exeter on Monday, 16 November, that she would issue a Prevention of Future Deaths report to Devon and Cornwall Police and the College of Policing after hearing that the force renewed John Perkins’s shotgun certificate in 2023 despite a GP’s record that he had been referred to anger management in April 2010 for slapping his wife. Mr Perkins shot Kathryn Perkins, 67, dead at their home in Briar Close, Exmouth, on 7 May 2025 and then himself, and the coroner recorded conclusions of unlawful killing and suicide.

For the trade the report matters less for what it says about one force than for who receives it. The College of Policing sets the professional practice every licensing department in England and Wales works to, and a recommendation on domestic abuse scrutiny addressed to it reaches every counter in the country.

What did the coroner find about the renewal?

Peter Ellis, giving evidence for the force’s firearms licensing department, said the 2010 incident was more than a decade old and that there was no record of domestic abuse on the force’s database. The 2023 application was made online and checked through the force’s usual information-sharing processes, and officers who visited the home heard no concerns from Mrs Perkins.

Mrs Longhorn said it would be “too speculative” to conclude that more enquiries would have changed the outcome, and acknowledged “a balancing exercise” by the firearm licensing manager. Her concern was the process: “I remain concerned that where somebody is applying for or renewing a firearm or shotgun licence application, the consideration scrutiny of a domestic abuse history does not appear as thorough or considered, or indeed as carefully or accurately documented as it should be.” She spoke of “what appears to be a lack of professional curiosity about the nature and extent of the domestic abuse history between the two”.

The regulatory clock the report starts

Under paragraph 7 of Schedule 5 to the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 a coroner must report where an investigation reveals a risk of further deaths that action could prevent. Regulation 29 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013 gives each recipient 56 days to set out the action it will take or explain why none is proposed, and the Chief Coroner publishes both the report and the responses. None had appeared by the morning of 17 November.

Devon and Cornwall Police told the court it is already changing how applications are considered where domestic abuse concerns are raised, work it said is not yet complete, and it made a voluntary referral to the Independent Office for Police Conduct after the deaths, in line with its practice on licensing matters. Its licensing was last under this kind of scrutiny after Jake Davison killed five people in the Keyham district of Plymouth in August 2021 with a legally held pump-action shotgun the force had returned to him.

Why the timing bears on the section 1 and 2 question

The Gun Trade Association has already warned that an inspectorate report in August revived the idea of bringing shotguns under section 1 of the Firearms Act 1968, ending the lighter section 2 certificate the shotgun trade has sold into for decades. A coroner’s finding that domestic abuse history is not scrutinised “as thorough or considered” as it should be on a shotgun renewal is exactly the kind of evidence that argument will cite, and the 56-day responses from a force and the college will be read in the Home Office as well as the coroner’s court.

The more immediate consequence is at the counter. The British Shooting Sports Council’s reading of the latest National Police Chiefs’ Council figures puts forces at 68.76% of applications decided within target. Each added check on household history, each further request to a GP and each enquiry officer told to ask more at the door adds days to a renewal already running behind, and a customer whose certificate lapses in the queue cannot take delivery.

What happens next

The report, once served, starts the 56-day clock for Devon and Cornwall Police and the College of Policing, and the responses will set out what either intends to change in practice. Dealers can watch for both on the Chief Coroner’s Prevention of Future Deaths pages. In the meantime a retailer taking a deposit against a renewal due in 2027 should allow for a longer process, and a customer with anything on an old record is better advised to raise it with the force, with its context, than to let an officer find it.


Useful links

Chief Coroner, Prevention of Future Deaths reports – where the report to Devon and Cornwall Police and the College of Policing, and their responses, will be published

College of Policing – the body that sets licensing practice for every force in England and Wales

Devon and Cornwall Police – the force that renewed the certificate and will answer the report

legislation.gov.uk – Regulation 28 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013, the power behind the report


Frequently asked questions

What is a Prevention of Future Deaths report?

A report a coroner must make under Schedule 5 to the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 when an investigation reveals a risk of further deaths that action could prevent. Recipients have 56 days to respond under Regulation 29 of the 2013 Regulations.

Who will receive the Exmouth report?

Devon and Cornwall Police, which renewed John Perkins’s shotgun certificate in 2023, and the College of Policing, which sets licensing practice nationally.

Does the Exmouth inquest affect the section 1 and section 2 review?

Not directly, but the Gun Trade Association has warned that an August inspectorate report revived the idea of bringing shotguns under section 1, and a coroner’s finding on renewal scrutiny is evidence that debate will use.


Related articles

Gun Trade Association report: 16-body coalition against shotgun reform – the trade’s stand against moving shotguns to section 1

Licensing overhaul goes on the statutory record – what the Chief Inspector’s report means for the trade

Police suitability checks: your right to answer untested allegations – how a holder answers what reaches the licensing department

Licensing backlog in Sussex: renewals bulge to hit dealers in 2027 – the renewal wave one force is already recruiting for